“Tin Cup” is being hyped as a brilliant romantic comedy. While this aspect of the movie is enjoyable, “Tin Cup’s” claim to fames should be its excellent sports drama.
Ron Shelton’s new golf movie brilliantly portrays one man’s physical and psychological growth, and lack of it, of a man questing to win the U.S. Open. Of course he makes the quest for a woman, but that only makes it Hollywood.
In fact the story of “Tin Cup” much parallels that of the sports classic “Hoosiers.” While this film’s drama is more personalized, the ups and down of making it big are chronicled nearly the same way in both. And common to the two films is the intensity of the drama - so strong that it becomes painful to watch the “good guys” lost at all.
I hope that by focusing on the sports side of this film, though, I don’t give the impression that the romance is poorly done. It is not. The chemistry between Kevin Costner and Rene Russo is in classic Hollywood style - unlikely, but all the more magical because of that.
Contributing to the both sports and the romantic stories, “Tin Cup” luckily takes time to develop the four main characters.
Kevin Costner plays driving range pro, former college golf star, and all-around good guy most of the time Roy “Tin Cup” McAvoy. He often gets himself into trouble with his unpredictable temper and fierce competitiveness, but these traits are also parts of his charm.
The object of his charms -Dr. Molly Griswold, played by Rene Russo - nearly steals the show. She is the classic Hollywood love interest with a 90s twist - the dreams of two men she can’t decide between.
Tin Cup’s opponent in both love and golf is David Simmes, wonderfully portrayed by Don Johnson. Simms represents everything McAvoy doesn't: reason, stability, and total predictability. And with those comparisons made, a question for you: Who will end up with the girl?
Illogically but pleasantly rounding and the foursome is Cheech Marin as Romeo, Tin Cup’s caddy. While Marin is known for his comic ability, he provides both poignancy and slapstick comedy. The scripting for and function of his character confuses the film sometimes, but Marin’s acting doesn’t.
Perhaps the beauty of “Tin Cup” can be found in its deeper messages. It sounds cliche, but this film has meaning worth paying attention to beneath the surface of the romantic comedy. But I won’t give them away; they’re more easily understood if you find them for yourself.
Deeper meaning or not, though, “Tin Cup” should be enjoyable for anyone. With romance, comedy, and athletics, all rolled in one, it makes for a pleasant and memorable two hours at the movies.
Grade: A